AMITIAE - Monday 2 July 2012
Cassandra - Monday Review: It will soon be Friday |
|
By Graham K. Rogers
Opening Gambit:Patent news to the fore: the tide is not going Google's way. Apple Mother Ship fast tracked by California Governor. Personnel changes and decisions. Comments on applications. Flash, a damp squib; RIM and Nokia dying: it is all Apple's fault. Nexus: an Asus in Google clothing. Nexus and Surface: landfill fodder. Revenge of the OEMs. Songs for A Clockwork Orange. True lose their numbers.
Apple StuffInstead of putting news of patents in Half and Half, the news this weekend has such a significance that it needs to be in this section on Apple stuff. Early in the weekend there was news reported by Foss Patents that the Judge, Lucy Koh, had allowed a temporary injunction against Samsung for one patent -- for Siri -- and dismissed some Samsung claims against Apple. Mikey Cambell on AppleInsider also had some information about one of the patents, including a diagram from the Patent filing.This was followed on Saturday by some more with the denial of a dozen of the Samsung claims against Apple. This is bad for Google too as this has almost been a proxy battle. To finish the job, Apple may have to withdraw some claims, but overall the comment by the Judge in her ruling --
Although Samsung has a right to compete, it does not have a right to compete unfairly, by flooding the market with infringing products -- does seem to suggest the way the wind is blowing. Not unsurprisingly, Samsung has filed an appeal about the ban, Florian Mueller reports on Foss Patents, and has moved to stay the injunction. Almost as a sidenote -- significant as it is -- we read on Foss Patents this Sunday that so far Android devices have been found to infringe 9 Apple patents, adding "the time has passed for any reasonable, unbiased person to deny that Android has a serious patent infringement problem that continues to exacerbate". Florian Mueller then lists 11 patents (2 are Microsoft's) but adds that there are some more minor ones that he has not mentioned. He concludes that the tide is not going Google's way.
Jeff Gamet on the MacObserver reports that Betsy Rafael, Apple vice president and Corporate Controller, will be retiring from the company on October 19, 2012. She joined Apple at the beginning of 2008 and has been responsible for managing the company's finances. A former Apple exec, Betrand Serlet who was also with Steve Jobs at NeXt is one of the forces behind a startup company who are working on "core technology for a Cloud OS" Electronista reports.
Although Mobile Me closed this weekend (I shifted to iCloud when Lion arrived) there may still be time to retrieve any data left on the site, Chris Oldroyd writes on iMore and explains how. This will not be there forever. 31 July is the final, final day.
I recorded a couple of brief clips while sitting in a mall and was surprised at how effective this was. I had recorded an 11 second clip at 40% speed then changed this to 1,000 fps turning it into a video some 6 min 20 sec in length with an almost painful slowness to the movement of shoppers walking past. I also converted a 36 second shot of water drops falling into a wine glass to a 500 fps video some 2 min 27 long. I transferred the edited video to the Mac via iTunes. It had been some 49 MB in the original export but in the super-slow 500fps form as the number of frames in the clip is increased, so the file size file was 139 MB. This will display full screen on the 15" MacBook Pro I have and looks good. Although I written about this before, I will be putting out a full review in a few days after I have used it for a while as the new version deserves it.
Half and HalfWhen Steve Jobs wrote his anti-Flash letter a couple of years back some of us new he was right. Some of us had suffered the effects of Flash overloading too many times on our Macs not to, something PC users did not realise as the software was written for them and sort of ported to the Mac. And not that well. Heaven forbid that the iPhone or iPad should suffer the same sorts of processor over-use, memory hogging and battery over-use (if you have a notebook computer). Steve Jobs said No: there was much wailing and gnashing of teeth. At least there was until others tried to put Flash on some of the devices whose makers said it would be OK: it most certainly was not and it dawned on some that Apple had been right after all.And then this weekend it was announced by Adobe that they would not be supporting Flash for the newest version of Android we read in an article by Jay Yarrow on Business Insider. The information was carried on countless sites in the last few days and Yarrow comments "Apple saw the death of Flash coming, and now its rivals look a little silly." Told you so. . . . In a slightly related article, John Shinai on Market Watch writes about how formerly powerful competitors like RIM and Nokia are fading fast, especially RIM. He also outlines the ways in which Steve Jobs and his team at Apple made certain strategic decisions concerning the iPhone, particularly the way software was the key. He explained that carefully at the 2007 Keynote Speech. I also remember sitting in the audience that day and marvelling at the way he brought the audience on as he introduced the "three new products." There was a big round of applause for the wide-screen iPod with touch controls, a roar when he introduced the new mobile phone, and polite applause at the "breakthrough internet communications device". I have run that video over and over again and it is clear to me that no one then could understand the implications; and yet it appears that this part of the iPhone (and the software) were the key factors in the success of the device.
Another version of Google Chrome is indeed crashing the new MacBook Air Topher Kessler writes, which Google does admit, "but suggests that while Chrome is causing the crashes, the problem also lies with how some of Apple's drivers are built." An update may be coming from Apple to deal with this.
Other MattersThere is more patent news this week, but this time it concerns Google and its completely independent, totally unconnected Motorola unit. Edward Moyer (among others) reports that the Federal Trade Commission is looking into how the company may have been "improperly blocking access to industry-standard technology that should be licensed to competitors according to traditional industry and legal practice." That is the FRAND patents that everyone gets to use but pays a fair price for the licence. The acronym means "Fair, Reasonable And Non-Discriminatory" so if you do not play fair, by definition the FRAND is no longer fair or reasonable, etc., with one Judge commenting on Motorola's attempt to have the Xbox banned, "I don't see how you can have [an] injunction against the use of a standard-essential patent." Saner minds do need to prevail.
One reviewer who actually had one of these in his hands for a few days is Drew Olanoff on TNW and his comments are available now. This is the first independent review I have seen of this. With the Nexus high on its agenda this week, Mountain View found time for a middle ranking executive to pass some time in an interview with Marguerite Reardon outlining the tablet device. Compare what a gung-ho Patrick Brady, director of Android partner engineering, says with what is above. Also we read in an item by Foss Patents that there are rather a lot of patents involved that might not belong to Google, with Apple, Nokia and Microsoft all represented in the mix. That is guaranteed to cause problems.
John Biggs on Tech Crunch writes that "HP and other OEMs are about to pull the plug on their own Windows on ARM RT (WART) devices thanks to Microsoft essentially beating them to market with potentially superior hardware." Of course, when it is financially agreeable at some time in the future, they will all be hugs and kisses again. There are also comments by Alex Wilhelm on TNW who looks at what the decision by HP means. The immediate conclusion is of course that Microsoft has upset a lot of companies, but he thinks that this is also the sound of bets being hedged.
So many investors expected that this would rise automatically and that they would be able to cash in within a week having all made themselves small fortunes. Instead they made small losses: a few dollars each share. They made it worse by trying to offload. The shares did pick up again a little after a few weeks, but have still not reached the IPO release price. I wrote weeks ago that if we look in (say) 6 months or a year at the price, there will be a better picture. The financial report coming in a couple of weeks may help focus a little, but the long-term view should be that Facebook will be a reasonably sound investment depending on how the services are monetized. But, as Facebook has already discovered: when you make changes, sometimes they do not work. The wrong changes may alienate users, and if they walk, Facebook has nothing.
Local ItemsThose who subscribe to the TV satellite and cable service (and I use the term, service, loosely) that True provides will also have a monthly guide that sometimes arrives before the first day of the month. This weekend I was looking through to see if there were any movies I wanted to watch (precious few I am afraid) and found a possibility for Sunday afternoon that was on the channel called Max. And what number channel is this? I have no idea now. While all issues of the guide before had the channel numbers (digital and analog), now they are no longer shown.If users do not have the channel preselected, it means scanning through scores to find something that might be watchable. And as for that remote control and its TV interfacing, the poor design, particularly with the preselection buttons and their associated colours, is a wonderful example of how to make something hard to use.
Graham K. Rogers teaches at the Faculty of Engineering, Mahidol University in Thailand. He wrote in the Bangkok Post, Database supplement on IT subjects. For the last seven years of Database he wrote a column on Apple and Macs. |
|
For further information, e-mail to