AMITIAE - Friday 12 October 2012
Cassandra - Friday Review - The Weekend Arrives |
|
By Graham K. Rogers
Opening Gambit:Civil war at Apple: Jobs' legacy and the overkill of skeuomorphic design. Purple haze: even Consumer Reports is happy. Aluminium bezel: chips, quality and strikes. New tracking for Ads: ON means ads are off. Sid Meier's Railroad Tycoon for the Mac. Fingerprint security gives up Windows passwords (Apple bought the company). Apple, Microsoft and patents: Google not such a good guy after all. Ballmer has another reduction in bonus (9% this time). Peachnote: a musical search engine. New Sony computers: one for use laid flat on a table. 3G in Thailand: on again, off again, maybe again.
Apple StuffHere is a new word, at least for some of you: skeuomorphism. This is used a lot with Apple software to give an appearance of a real item, for example the leather stitching at the top of the Calendar application on OS X; or the binding at the top of Notes. Some people like this, and Steve Jobs was one. Others do not and Austin Carr (is that a pseudonym?) on Fast Company outlines a near-revolt that is continuing at Apple with mini-Me Scott Forestall a supporter of such design excesses (you can tell where I stand), "while industrial designer Jony Ive and other Apple higher-ups are said to oppose the direction", he writes.I hated the Calendar finish when it arrived and far preferred the neutral finish of the earlier version, while iBooks is a useful design and that other one I mentioned, Notes, is not overdone. Some are. There is much useful input in the article about the ideas conveyed by this form of design, which some regard as outmoded, although there are other, stronger comments. While Carr comments (helpfully),
It's important to note that not all visual metaphors are bad. Rather, it's the excessive UI adornments of these visual metaphors that many insiders I've spoken with find distasteful and inherently confusing. My source for this useful item was MacDaily News who include some diplomatic comments from Jony Ive.
Earth-shifting in terms of stock would not describe a smaller form tablet computer that many have been expecting but extra icing as suggested in this article could add that must-have quality that lifts the share prices again. Schwarz reckons that a $350 price would be good but if it comes in at $299 that would hit a sweet spot and sales could be phenomenal.
You will note in the shot that is on the AppleInsider page, that although purple (or mauve) is predominant, there are also other colours streaming out from the center.
Another useful item on this on Bloomberg, written by Tim Culpan, Alexandra Ho and Adam Satariano, confirms the choice of a specific type of aluminium as a source of the problems and mentioned Phil Schiller's crass comment about normal use: out of the box, is not normal use. However, there have been follow ups at the factories and this has caused a knock-on effect: shortages and unhappy staff. It is not a complete surprise to hear the (perhaps related) news that Apple is to bring in another manufacturer for the iPhone called Foxconn International. The Tell on Market Watch explains the details. My original source for this was MacDaily News.
My link for this was MacDaily News.
PC Mag also thinks the iPod touch is nice and the review by Sascha Segan is positive with him calling it, "the most elegant device I've ever handled - and yes, that includes the iPhone 5."
Sometimes wishes come true, sort of, and a report by Peter Cohen on The Loop tells me that a new version of Railroad Tycoon, called Sid Meier's Railroads (there's a combination) is coming to the Mac this fall: surely that is now. This was originally a Windows version we are told, and the system requirements are detailed on the Feral Interactive website, where pre-orders are also possible.
Half and HalfApple recently bought a company for its technical abilities in fingerprint technology, but there appear to be some security problems with the software as Dan Goodin on Ars Technica reports that it can apparently be exploited to recover Windows account passwords. The software has been around a long time, and Apple has only had the company a few months, so there is unlikely to be any integration with iOS or OS X, but this will need to be fixed.
Sometimes Asian students just do not get this concept of originality because from high school days copying is drilled into them as a way of producing work and the mark of a good student is not the content, but a beautiful cover. Time and time again I have to try and convince (unsuccessfully in some cases) my students, that just because they have read something in a book and remembered it, this does not mean they know the information and it does not need citing as a reference. Read, turn round three times and I know this. . . . Maybe that was the approach of some design teams: look at the iPhone, go home, have a sleep, then come back the next morning and draw that new device that will slay the dragon. There is also the question of FRAND patents and Samsung may have to learn what the ownership of these patents really means: not a free for all to selectively charge a licence to the one who will pay the most, but a fair and reasonable fee. Google as owners of Motorola also seem to have selective problems with such patents and an interesting article on Patently Apple outlines the efforts by the authorities (Department of Justice, FTC and International Telecommunication Union -- quite a team) who are not convinced by Google's take on the use of essential patents. The DoJ has praised Apple (gasp) and Microsoft (gasp again) for their approach to fair licensing but are concerned about Google's "ambiguous" approach and complain that the company "do not provide the same direct confirmation of its standard-essential patent licensing policies." There is much more in the item. The information originated in the NYTimes and has been carried by other sources, but Patently Apple highlights some of the more significant passages that suggest that Google and Samsung (as we have said a number of times before) are just not playing fair with this licensing and their "good guy" routine in public while authorities "see a much different legal stand that Google is definitely using that is anything but good for the technology sector."
Other MattersGreat Scott! Here's a thought and one that I am sure will have many shifting uncomfortably in their seats. According to a Reuters report that I saw, Ballmer sees Microsoft becoming more like Apple, as if they haven't been trying to copy for the last few years. While confirming that Redmond will still be working with hardware partners (did you feel the relief from the direction of Taiwan) he was referring to services: MS has realised the cloud has potential. Let's see if they can muck that up as well.In the same article it was reported that (again) the CEO got a lower bonus than last year: down 9%. Reason: flat sales and poor browser choice for European customers. Another Reuters' report by Bill Rigby covered the bonus decision on its own.
The VAIO Tap 20 is a family tabletop PC designed to take advantage of the intuitive ease of Windows 8. Featuring a 20-inch screen, this mobile desktop PC can lay flat on a coffee table for the whole family to play games on the large screen. With a removable battery, users can easily move it from room to room in the house. The Vaio Tap 20 starts at $879.99 and comes in Black or White. Duo 11 starts at $1099.99 and comes in Black. Wasn't there criticism of Apple last week because the iPhone 5 was only in black or white?
Local ItemsOn again, off again, maybe. Although the NBTC said all was OK with the 3G auction earlier in the week, the Bangkok Post was reporting on Thursday morning that there were still legal challenges hanging like the Sword of Damocles over the process; and "If the court issues an urgent emergency injunction against the 3G bid, it would force the NBTC to suspend the auction, scheduled for next Tuesday." The Post did not actually use the term, Sword of Damocles: that was a classical literary flourish from me.
Late NewsLate news in an item by Don Sambandaraksa on Telecom Asia about TOT and its failed 3G business plan with the additional news that the CAT board has "decided to halt the controversial TrueMoveH 3G project after both the counter-corruption commission and the ICT Ministry have deemed the contract to be illegal."Just in time for the iPhone 5. . . .
Graham K. Rogers teaches at the Faculty of Engineering, Mahidol University in Thailand. He wrote in the Bangkok Post, Database supplement on IT subjects. For the last seven years of Database he wrote a column on Apple and Macs. |
|
For further information, e-mail to